5th Circuit Proxy Voting Ruling: Court Declares COVID-Era House Voting Unconstitutional
A major legal development in the United States has brought congressional voting procedures and constitutional law into the spotlight. On November 20, 2026, the full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled that the House of Representatives violated the Constitution when it used pandemic-era proxy voting to establish a quorum while passing a major government spending bill in 2022.
The 9-8 decision has attracted national attention because it raises important questions about how Congress conducts its business, whether lawmakers must be physically present to count toward a quorum, and whether legislation passed during the COVID-19 pandemic could face further legal challenges.
The ruling also affects the enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against the State of Texas, making it an important development for employment law and constitutional litigation.

What Is the 5th Circuit Proxy Voting Ruling?
The Fifth Circuit proxy voting ruling concerns a voting procedure introduced by the U.S. House of Representatives during the COVID-19 pandemic.
In May 2020, the House introduced a temporary system allowing lawmakers who could not physically attend sessions to cast their votes through another member of Congress. This system was called proxy voting.
The procedure was introduced to allow congressional business to continue while reducing the health risks associated with large gatherings during the pandemic.
However, the State of Texas challenged the legality of this system. It argued that lawmakers who were absent from the House chamber could not be counted as physically present when determining whether the chamber had the required quorum to pass legislation.
On November 20, 2026, the full Fifth Circuit agreed with Texas and ruled that proxy presence could not count toward the constitutional quorum requirement.
What Did the Fifth Circuit Court Decide?
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, sitting en banc, decided the case by a 9-8 majority.
The majority concluded that the Constitution's Quorum Clause requires members of Congress to be physically present when determining whether a quorum exists.
The court examined the constitutional text, historical understanding and congressional practice. It concluded that the House could not change this constitutional requirement simply by adopting its own procedural rules.
Judge Cory Wilson wrote the majority opinion.
The ruling upheld the lower court's decision preventing the federal government from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas.
Importantly, the decision did not cancel the entire federal spending law or automatically invalidate every law passed using proxy voting.
What Is Proxy Voting in Congress?
Proxy voting allows one elected representative to cast a vote on behalf of another representative who is unable to attend a session.
During the COVID-19 emergency, the House of Representatives adopted this procedure to maintain legislative operations while reducing physical gatherings.
Under the system, an absent member could authorise another member to record their vote.
The arrangement allowed Congress to continue considering legislation despite travel restrictions, health concerns and other pandemic-related difficulties.
However, the constitutional dispute focused on a different question: Can an absent member be counted as present when calculating the quorum required for the House to conduct official business?
The Fifth Circuit's answer was no.
Why Did Texas Challenge Proxy Voting?
The legal challenge was brought by the State of Texas during the administration of Republican Attorney General Ken Paxton.
Texas argued that the House had improperly counted absent lawmakers toward a quorum when passing the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023.
The legislation was a $1.7 trillion government funding package passed in December 2022.
The package included several important provisions, including the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.
Texas challenged the law's validity, arguing that the House had not satisfied the Constitution's quorum requirement because proxy votes were counted toward the necessary number of members.
The case became known as State of Texas v. Blanche, case number 24-10386.

What Is the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act?
The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, commonly known as the PWFA, is a federal employment law that provides workplace protections for employees affected by pregnancy, childbirth and related medical conditions.
The law requires covered employers to provide reasonable workplace accommodations unless doing so would create an undue hardship for the employer.
Examples of possible accommodations include:
Additional breaks for drinking water or using the restroom.
Temporary changes to physically demanding duties.
Adjustments to work schedules.
Permission to sit or take breaks when needed.
Temporary changes in workplace responsibilities.
The legislation was designed to help pregnant employees continue working safely without being unnecessarily forced to take leave.
The Fifth Circuit's decision has created uncertainty about federal enforcement of these protections against Texas.
Does the Ruling Affect Pregnant Workers Across the United States?
This is one of the most important questions surrounding the decision.
The Fifth Circuit upheld an injunction preventing federal enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against the State of Texas.
However, the ruling does not automatically eliminate the law across the entire United States.
The case involved Texas as the employer and the specific relief requested in that lawsuit. The court's judgment was limited to the enforcement issue involving Texas.
It is therefore important to distinguish between the court's constitutional reasoning and the actual legal relief granted.
Private employers across the country should not assume that the ruling automatically removes their obligations under the PWFA.
Workers and employers should seek qualified legal guidance about how the decision applies to their particular circumstances.
Why Was the Fifth Circuit Decision 9-8?
The decision was closely divided, with nine judges supporting the majority and eight opposing it.
The majority opinion was written by Judge Cory Wilson. It concluded that the Constitution requires members to be physically present to count toward a quorum.
The dissenting judges disagreed with this interpretation.
Judge James Graves Jr. argued that the Constitution also gives each chamber of Congress authority to determine its own procedural rules.
The dissent questioned whether the court's interpretation gave sufficient importance to Congress's constitutional power to manage its own proceedings.
The disagreement demonstrates how constitutional language can produce different legal interpretations, particularly when historical practice and modern emergency procedures are involved.

Could Other Laws Passed During the Pandemic Be Challenged?
The decision could have implications beyond the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.
The $1.7 trillion spending package included numerous other provisions, and the majority's constitutional reasoning may encourage additional legal challenges.
Some provisions that have attracted attention include:
TikTok restrictions on government devices: The spending package included a federal restriction on the use of TikTok on government-owned devices.
Electoral Count Reform Act: The legislation also included reforms governing the congressional counting of electoral votes during presidential elections.
Other federal spending provisions: Additional measures contained in the package could become subjects of legal debate.
However, it is essential to understand that the Fifth Circuit did not strike down these provisions in this case. Any future challenge would need to proceed through separate legal proceedings.
What Happens Next After the 5th Circuit Ruling?
The decision is likely to generate further legal debate.
The federal government could seek review from the U.S. Supreme Court.
If the Supreme Court agrees to hear the case, it could examine whether proxy voting is compatible with the Constitution's Quorum Clause and whether the Fifth Circuit interpreted the issue correctly.
Another important question is whether the decision's reasoning will be used in challenges involving other legislation passed during the pandemic.
Until further legal developments occur, the November 20 decision remains an important ruling in the dispute over congressional proxy voting.
Why Is the 5th Circuit Proxy Voting Ruling Important?
The decision is significant for several reasons.
1. Constitutional Interpretation
It addresses the meaning of the Quorum Clause and whether physical presence is required for congressional business.
2. Congressional Procedures
It raises questions about how the House can adapt its procedures during emergencies.
3. Employment Rights
The ruling affects federal enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas.
4. Future Legal Challenges
Its reasoning could influence lawsuits involving other legislation passed through pandemic-era congressional procedures.
5. The Role of Federal Courts
The decision demonstrates how courts can review disputes involving constitutional limits on congressional authority.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the 5th Circuit proxy voting ruling?
It is a November 20, 2026 decision in which the Fifth Circuit ruled 9-8 that the House of Representatives could not count absent members voting by proxy toward a constitutional quorum.
2. When did the Fifth Circuit issue its decision?
The full Fifth Circuit issued its decision on November 20, 2026.
3. What case involved the proxy voting dispute?
The case is State of Texas v. Blanche, Fifth Circuit case number 24-10386.
4. Why did the House introduce proxy voting?
The House introduced proxy voting during the COVID-19 pandemic to allow lawmakers to participate in legislative proceedings without needing to attend sessions physically.
5. What is the Quorum Clause?
The Quorum Clause is part of Article I, Section 5 of the U.S. Constitution. It establishes that a majority of each chamber must be present to conduct business.
6. Does the ruling cancel the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act?
No. The ruling upholds an injunction against federal enforcement of the law against Texas. It does not repeal the Act nationwide.
7. Can the decision be appealed?
The federal government can seek review by the U.S. Supreme Court. Whether the Supreme Court agrees to hear the case is a separate question.
Conclusion
The 5th Circuit proxy voting ruling is an important development in American constitutional law. By ruling that absent lawmakers cannot count toward a congressional quorum through proxy voting, the court has placed renewed attention on the relationship between constitutional requirements and congressional procedures.
The decision also has practical consequences for the enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas.
Although the ruling has raised questions about other pandemic-era legislation, it does not automatically invalidate the entire 2022 spending package or remove pregnancy-related workplace protections nationwide.
The next major development could come from the U.S. Supreme Court, making this a legal issue worth following in the coming months.

